Tom Endler

Principal Kinney

Grace Wesley

School Attorney

Judge Stennis

Brooke Thawley

Walter Wesley

Martin Yip

Amy Ryan

Superintendent Jim Powell

Catherine Thawley

Reverend Jude

Marlene

Senior Pastor

Pastor Dave Hill

Peter Kane

Waiter

Rice Broocks

Susan Stone

Mrs. Rizzo

Rev. Dave Double

First Teacher

Jessica

Goth Girl

Crazy Cat Lady

Frazzled Teacher

Fashionista

Gary Habermas

Sunny Barista

Salvation Army Lady

Mike Huckabee

Bailiff

County Clerk

Slacker Kid

Prospective Juror

Male Journalist

Simon Boyle

Paramedic

Norma

V.P. of Teachers Union

Teenage Girl

Pharmacist

Female Juror

Elizabeth Healy

Older Man

Lee Strobel

Jury Forman

Jim Warner Wallace

Martin's Father

The Newsboys

The Newsboys

The Newsboys

The Newsboys

Concert Patron (uncredited)

Jury Extra (uncredited)

Courtroom observer (uncredited)

Medical Staff (uncredited)

Food Truck Patron (uncredited)

Gallery Observer (uncredited)

Lawyer (uncredited)

Protestor (uncredited)

Waitress (uncredited)

Extra (uncredited)

Courtroom Observer (uncredited)

Paramedic (uncredited)

Student (trouble maker) (uncredited)

Protester Shaking Jesse Metcalfe Hand (uncredited)

Supporter (uncredited)

Juror #6 (uncredited)

Background (uncredited)

Timid Pastor (uncredited)

Courtroom Observer / Protester (uncredited)

Courtroom Observer (uncredited)

Juror (uncredited)

Courtroom Gallery / Protestor (uncredited)

Courtroom Observer / Reporter (uncredited)

Concert patron (uncredited)

Classmate (uncredited)

Extra (uncredited)

Protester (uncredited)

Protester (uncredited)

Protester (uncredited)

Concert Attendee (uncredited)

Concert Patron (uncredited)

Lawyer Assistant (uncredited)

Extra (uncredited)

Reporter (uncredited)

Concert Patron (uncredited)

Extra (uncredited)

Richard Thawley