John Chisum

Lawrence Murphy

Dan Nodeen

James Pepper

Pat Garrett

Alex McSween

Sheriff Brady

Henry Tunstall

Jess Evans

Sue McSween

Billy 'The Kid' Bonney

Sallie Chisum

Amos Patton

Neemo

Bradley Morton

Tom O'Folliard

James J. Dolan

Justice J.B. Wilson

Charley Bowdre

Baker

Colonel Nathan Dudley

Gov. Sam Axtell

Juan Delgado

Jeff - Head Wrangler

Ben

Sgt. Braddock

Chief White Buffalo

Karl Riker

Stationmaster Elwood

Mexican Rancher

Trace - Wrangler

Cass

Pegleg on Street

Narrator - Opening Credits (voice) (uncredited)

Governor's Aide (uncredited)

Doctor (uncredited)

Boy on Town (uncredited)

Minister (uncredited)

Wrangler (uncredited)

Young Boy Loading Wagon (uncredited)

Young Girl (uncredited)

Sallie's Mother (picture in Chisum's Pocketwatch) (uncredited)

Trail Herder (uncredited)

Mexican Blacksmith (uncredited)

Blacksmith (uncredited)

Blacksmith (uncredited)

Extra (uncredited)