Tyler St.James: The Muscle Fantasy brings newcomers Johnny and Tyler sitting on the casting couch waiting for girl to show up so they can double team her on camera. The director eventually tells them both that the girl is a no-show and that if they'd be willing to fool around with each other the shoot will continue and they will be paid double. Tyler and Dereck are long-time friends, typically working together a few times a week at least but Tyler hasn't been around lately. During todays session Tyler won't stop talking about the club chick he met who is also the reason that he has been missing workout sessions with his friend. Dereck tells Tyler that he fucked her too not thinking it was a big deal, but it turns out to be a HUGE deal sending Tyler into a rage. Tyler pushes Dereck telling him that the only way to make this up to him is to let Tyler fuck him. Tyler takes control and gives Derek the punishment fuck of his life!