Self (archive footage)

Grace The Reporter

John Murphy

(archive footage)

Brandon

Stacy Miller

Chad

Miguel 'Snakeskin' Perez

Samael 'Sam' Dubhan

Karen

Self (archive footage)

Ted Bundy Admirer

Agent Walker

Jared Oakley

Kelly Thompson (segment: Cable 54 News - Why Do Killers Kill?)

Piper Lopez

Roxie

Bill Carl

Officer Joe Newton

Serena

Biker

Parker Rhodes

Victim's Sister

Interviewee

Jan Parsons - Criminal Psychology

Hunter Schmidt

Victim's Friend

Young kid

Officer Thompson

Interviewee

Johnny Starr

Crazy fan

Detective Mark Agnello / President of Necrophiliacs Anonymous

Detective

Robert

Dr. Ian Gensuse (segment "Sue")

Actress

Alejandra Gomez

Serial Killer Fan

Sara (segment "Made For You")

Simon / Killer

Brandons Nephew

Interviewee

Det. Wilson Brown

Martin (segment "Made For You")

Deranged Interviewer

V (Segment "Fear the Ghetto Killer")

Criminal Psychologist

Cousin #2

Michaela Lillestol

Victim's Friend

Sam

Family Friend

Miles Thornbush

Tom Smith

Ted Bundy Fan

Killer in Van #2

Reid's mom

Max Caulfield

Jeronomo Rozebush

Sue Tralfero (segment "Sue")

Louie

Ralph Witkins

Doctor

Annabelle Thornbush

Victim

Witness

Perpetrator

Mike (segment "Poetry in That")

Drew Holland

Conspiracy Guy

Girl in Van #2

Jimmy

Young Brandon

Adrian

Harper Bennet

Zoey 'FreaqShow' Peterson

Karen

James Hartley

Alan

Interviewee

J.R. Wilson

Junior (segment "Cruel Yule")

Victim's Sister

Dave (segment "Poetry in That")

young Reid

Cousin #1

Victim (segment "Cruel Yule")

Reporter (voice)

Ashley

Cameron Patrick

Owen Walsh

Ruby Collingwood

Pearl

Victim

Roe

Jean

Firsherman

Brandon Fan (segment "Brandon Lives")

Ron Stone

Jeremy

Girl in Van #1

Raped Girl (segment "Brandon Lives")

Danny Stevens

Peyton Prescott

Hunter