A Mississippi mother brings her college fling to court to prove that he fathered her daughter 23 years ago, a secret she has kept from her daughter.
A Michigan man deflowers his girlfriend but doubts he's the father of her 3-year-old daughter.
After catching his girlfriend in a lie, a man from Ohio suspects she cheated and gave birth to another man's son.
A Virginia man summons two sisters to court to prove that he is their father. [Part 2 of 2]
A Virginia man summons two sisters to court to prove that he is their father, rather than the man they have called Dad for 30 years. [Part 1 of 2]
A mother from Michigan claims that, before his passing, her son confessed that he doubted the paternity of his girlfriend's daughter.
A California woman is livid that her ex denies her 2-year-old, but he claims she was sleeping with another man when she conceived.
A furious woman brings to court her deceased boyfriend's mother to prove that she is her 3-month-old daughter's grandmother.
Despite their seven-year relationship and having twin girls together, a Florida woman comes to court to prove that her ex is not the father of her 2-year-old son.
A 22-year-old woman brings the man she's always believed to be her father after he confesses his doubts surrounding her mother's promiscuity.
A 35-year-old woman finds out that a man whom she has never met may be her biological father.
After her live-in boyfriend passes away, a Maryland woman summons his parents to court to prove he fathered her 4-year-old daughter.
An impetuous one-night stand leaves two strangers feuding over the paternity of a 3-year-old girl.
After his wife leaves him to cheat with his friend, a man from Georgia claims it's impossible he could have fathered her child.
After 19 years of paying child support, a Detroit man gets to meet his daughter, then denies paternity.
Still grieving the tragic death of her son, a mother summons his estranged ex-girlfriend to court to prove he is not the father of her 4-year-old son.
Judge Lake takes a look back at some of the courtroom's most outrageous couples to see if their relationships survived after paternity secrets were revealed.
After seven miscarriages, a woman at last gives birth to a child, then her fiancé doubts he's the father.
After hearing sex noises coming from his ex-girlfriend's house, a man now questions the paternity of her child.
He took her virginity before passing away, and now a young woman is in court to prove to her ex-lover's family that he fathered her child.
Thirty years of living in lies and secrecy come to a screeching halt when a desperate mother brings her ex-fling to court to learn the truth about who fathered her daughter.
A prenatal DNA test provided a couple with two conflicting results, and they come to Judge Lake to get the truth regarding the paternity of a 4-month-old baby boy.
A game of tit-for-tat leads a couple from Michigan to doubt the paternity of their two little girls.
A woman says her husband is neglecting their child because he has a baby with his new girlfriend; he says he suspects her ex is her daughter's father.
A North Carolina woman brings her "side guy" to court to prove that he is the biological father of her 2-year-old son.
After discovering that her "deceased" father is still alive, a 25-year-old woman meets the man who vanished out of her life after her birth.
Judge Lake takes a look back at some of the courtroom's most outrageous couples to see whether their relationships survived after their paternity secrets were revealed.
Filled with regret, a Tennessee man brings his ex-fling to court to prove that he is not the father of her 3-year-old daughter.
Sex with two men on the same day raises questions as to who fathered a 13-month-old boy.
A man refuses to believe he is the father of his girlfriend's newborn and has concrete evidence to prove that another man is.
A man calls his much-younger ex-girlfriend a gold-digger and denies fathering her 3-year-old daughter.
A deceased man's family brings to court a woman who claims to be the mother of his child.
A California man is ready to unmask his cheating wife and is certain that her 4-month-old child is not his.
A failed lie-detector test and an admission of cheating lead a man to believe that he is not the father of his girlfriend's 3-year-old son.
After multiple sexual encounters with her next-door neighbor, a Chicago woman is desperate to prove that he fathered her 7-month-old daughter.
Despite being raised by another man, a 32-year-old woman from Arkansas is convinced that her mother's ex-husband is her biological father.
A Florida woman comes to court to uncover the truth behind her ex-boyfriend's constant denial of her 1-year-old daughter.
After a whirlwind love affair and discovering his girlfriend is pregnant, a man disappears, saying another man is the father.
They had sexual encounters on her back porch and the back seat of his car, and now a Chicago man denies fathering his ex-lover's daughter.
New York tempers flare as a man and his girlfriend bring "the other woman" to court to prove he did not father her 3-month-old daughter.
In an effort to save her marriage, a woman brings her husband to court to put a stop to his endless accusations and prove once and for all that he is the biological father of her 6-month-old son.
A 32-year-old man believes his entire family perished in a house fire when he was a child, until another man steps up saying he's his biological father.
Two women come to court to find out if a grieving mother's deceased son fathered their children.
A woman receives a sexually explicit text message from another man that leaves her former fiance doubting the paternity of her daughter.
A 25-year-old woman and her family come to court to find out if the man she grew up calling Dad is really her biological father.
After his girlfriend went on a camping trip with another man, an Illinois man questions if he is her son's biological father.
Three men are implicated in the paternity of one child. [Part 2 of 2]
A mess hits the courtroom when three men are implicated in the paternity of one child. [Part 1 of 2]
A weekend fling may have produced a love child 36 years ago; a woman from South Carolina confronts the man who abandoned her three decades ago.
Rumors of his wife's adulterous activities has a man from Illinois doubting the paternity of her seventh child.
An 18-year-old woman claims her 42-year-old ex-lover begged her to have his baby, but he and his daughter have paternity doubts due to her admitted infidelity.
After engaging in a threesome 20 years ago, a mother from Virginia is determined to help her daughter find her true biological father.
A Texas woman summons her ex-boyfriend to court to prove that he is the biological father of her almost-27-year-old son, after he has been dodging and ducking a paternity test.
After tragically losing their brother, two grieving sisters from Michigan want to restore their family name by proving he did not father his ex-girlfriend's child.
A woman feels betrayed when her mother and sister fuel her boyfriend's doubts that he is the father of her son.
After her father confesses his 33-year doubt, a woman from Texas is utterly destroyed and must come to court to uncover the truth.
Two brothers are in court to find out if one brother got his older brother's wife pregnant, more than 30 years ago. [Part 2 of 2]
Two brothers with the same name are in court to find out if the younger brother got his older brother's wife pregnant, more than 30 years ago. [Part 1 of 2]
An anonymous text claiming that another man got his girlfriend pregnant causes a North Carolina man to doubt fathering her 1-month-old daughter.
A music promoter from Georgia believes he is not the father of his ex-girlfriend's baby.
An Indiana man comes to court to prove that he's not the biological father. [Part 2 of 2]
An Indiana man comes to court to prove that he's not the biological father of either of his ex-girlfriend's sons. [Part 1 of 2]
An Illinois couple summon their friend to court to find out if a hot threesome date turned into a due date.
A woman betrayed a man's trust and cheated with a roommate; her boyfriend is in court to prove that he is the father of her 8-month-old daughter.
Two men are caught in a web of lies spun by the woman whom they slept with five years earlier; paternity tests may reveal the truth.
A Mississippi man brings his ex-girlfriend to court, adamant that he is the father of her 4-year-old daughter.
A woman reveals the identity of her 30-year-old daughter's biological father before passing away; the man denies ever meeting the mother.
A Texas woman claims she's the offspring of a man who's now deceased.
It's a case of deceit and deception when a Pennsylvania woman brings her boyfriend and secret lover to court to determine who fathered her 2-month-old son.
A 27-year marriage is on thin ice because a man from California questions the paternity of his 4-year old daughter.
An Arkansas woman brings her ex-boyfriend to court to prove that he is the father. [Part 2 of 2]
A paternity bombshell is dropped when an Arkansas woman brings her ex-boyfriend to court to prove that he is the biological father of her 2-month-old daughter. [Part 1 of 2]
Two weeks after their engagement is called off due to paternity questions, an Alabama woman brings her ex-fiance to court to prove that he is the biological father of her 20-month-old son.
A distressed mother is demanding financial help from the man she claims is the biological father of her child who has a rare medical condition.
A Muslim woman claims her husband is her 6-month-old daughter's biological father, while he denies paternity -- and their marriage.
Rumors of cheating has a Mississippi man suspicious over the paternity of a child he has raised since birth.
She had sex with her husband's family member and her ex, and now her husband claims he is not the father of her nine-month-old son.
A 26-year-old Texas woman summons her mother to court for paternity fraud after she finds out that she has four potential fathers.
After being referred to Paternity Court by Couples Court with the Cutlers, a woman wants to prove that her husband fathered her daughter.
A heartbroken Texas man brings his current girlfriend to court to finally put his doubts to rest about the paternity of her 3-month-old baby boy.
There's drama in the courtroom when a Georgia woman faces a former friend, who claims her son fathered her 3-month-old baby.
A Kentucky woman brings her ex-boyfriend to court to prove that he is the father of her 29-year-old daughter, after telling him that he wasn't years ago.
Tired of her ex-boyfriend dodging child support, the mother of a 3-year-old child brings her ex to court to prove that he is the biological father of her son.
A swinger couple comes to court after a night of fun involving another man leaves the paternity of their 3-month-old daughter in question.
Exhausted from years of denial, a Georgia woman brings her husband to court to demand he steps up as the father to her two-year-old son.
A Georgia woman, representing her deceased father, brings a woman to court to prove that he did not father her two daughters.
The mother of a 1-month-old child brings her high school sweetheart to court to prove her one-night stand left no real consequences, and that HE is the father of her child.
Her best friend texted her boyfriend that he's not the father and now a Michigan woman is in court to prove paternity and save her relationship.
After 26 years of living in the dark, a distraught woman comes to court to prove her paterntity to the man she has known as her father her entire life.
The single mother of a 3-month-old boy, brings her unsupportive ex-boyfriend to court, demanding that he stops ignoring his paternal responsibilities.
After being cheated on multiple times, a Virginia man brings his girlfriend to court -- he refuses to continue to live a lie and needs to know if he's the biological father of her two sons.
A first date produces a due date and now a Georgia woman is determined to prove that her ex-boyfriend is the biological father of her 4-month-old son.
Judge Lake reveals DNA test results for a 22-year-old Missouri woman who has never met, seen, or spoken to the man she was always told is her father.
In the midst of planning her wedding, a Georgia woman brings her fiancé to court to prove that he is the biological father of her 4-year-old daughter.
A Tennessee woman admits to cheating on her husband several times but brings him to court to prove he is her son's biological father.
An Ohio man comes to Paternity Court to prove that he's not the biological father of his girlfriend's 1-month-old son, as the baby does not carry a specific family trait.
A woman from California confronts the man she has always known to be her biological father after he disappeared on her 20 years before.
A Tennessee man claims that a young woman was the result of an almost decade-long affair he had with a married woman.
After the tragic loss of her lover, an Indiana woman comes to court to prove to his parents that her daughter is their grandchild.
A woman from Missouri says her ex-boyfriend is the biological father of her 10-month-old son, but he claims that another man is.
A Michigan woman brings her boyfriend to court to prove he is the biological father of her 2-month-old fraternal twins.
After forgiving his ex-wife for cheating on him eleven times, a divorced man doubts the paternity of her 2-year-old daughter.
A New York man questions the paternity of his wife's 4-year-old daughter and undergoes a sperm analysis test to determine his ability to father a child.
Philadelphia mother brings ex-boyfriend to court to prove that he is the father of her 6-month-old baby girl. She's tired of him denying paternity and wants him to step up.
A woman from Michigan is determined to vindicate her deceased son with the results of a DNA test.
An Alabama man brings his unfaithful ex-fiancé to court, seeking to uncover the truth surrounding the paternity of her 1-month-old baby girl.
It's an emotional day in Paternity Court when a 24-year-old Missouri man confronts his alleged father for abandoning him after his mother died in a car accident.
A Georgia man and his new fiancée dispute the paternity of his ex-girlfriend's 3-year-old daughter.
An Alabama man summons his summer fling to court to prove he has been trapped in a web of lies and that he is not the father of her 3-month old child.
Two Alabama men appear in court, both firm in the belief that they fathered the defendant's 4-year-old son.
A traveling salesman had a "fling" with a married woman and is accused of fathering her 2-year-old daughter.
An Alabama woman brings her ex-boyfriend to court to prove to him that he is the father of her 3-year-old son. She demands that he stops dodging his paternal responsibilities.
A self-proclaimed promiscuous Georgia woman brings her ex-boyfriend to court to prove that he is the father of her son - not her sugar daddy!
A woman brings her boyfriend of four years to court to prove that he's the biological father of her child, but is taken by surprise when her twin sister testifies that he may not be.
Caught in a love triangle, an Ohio man and his girlfriend bring his ex-girlfriend to court to prove he is not the father of her baby girl; but in a surprising twist his current girlfriend's 1-month-old son is called into question.
Seeking financial help to raise her 18-month-old son, a Georgia woman brings to court the family of the deceased man, who she claims is her son's father.
After a messy divorce and years of paternity doubt, a woman brings her ex-husband to court to prove he fathered her 19 year old daughter.
A young mother is hopeful that her high school crush is the father of her 10-month-old son, but admits she was also involved with another man.
The mother of an 8-month-old boy is looking to prove to her ex-boyfriend, and his new fiancé, that he is undoubtedly the biological father of her son.
A woman from Georgia brings two men to court to set the record straight, after lying to both of them about the paternity of her daughter.
