In Shreveport, LA, best friends Jeanie Phelps and Patty Thorington investigate the murder of Jeanie's sister Carol Ann; after four decades of searching, Carol Ann's remains are formally identified. Their epic fight to get justice for Carol Ann has become a lifelong quest.

In 2010, 29-year-old Hera McLeod set up an online dating profile and soon met the man of her dreams; however, shortly after giving birth to their son, a shocking betrayal proves that everything she knew about him was a lie and she needs to protect her son from a dangerous killer.

In 2006, a brutal crime takes place in the backwoods of Gregg County, TX. Two hunters find the body of the unidentified young woman. The victim’s identity eludes police for more than a decade. The volunteers of the DNA Doe Project aim to give her back her name and help bring a killer to justice.

In Pensacola, Florida, independent journalist Rick Outzen is drawn into the murder investigation of a local couple known for adopting special needs children. Rick’s investigative tactics provide crucial insight into one of Florida’s most notorious crimes.

A young father of two is found shot in in his tent on a camping trip in idyllic Malibu Creek State Park; resident citizen journalist Cece Woods uncovers a string of unreported shootings in the area leading up to the murder.

In St. John's County, FL, in 2010, Sherriff Deputy Jeremy Banks' girlfriend dies of an apparent suicide, but the evidence doesn't add up. Years later, an amateur investigator looking into the case meets the same tragic fate. Now, two citizen sleuths team up to piece together what really happened.