When Teddy gets accepted into a college in New York City, she goes to New York, alongside P.J. P.J stays at a hot dog cart and gets back together with Skyler. Meanwhile Teddy misses her tour on the subway and meets up with Jessie and Zuri. When a blizzard traps Teddy and P.J in New York City, they decide to stay with Jessie and Zuri.
After Teddy uncovers the reason why Amy and her younger sister Jamie drifted apart, she and Charlie quickly devise a plan to convince Amy that it's time to make things right with her sister. Meanwhile, Gabe and Jake sell a photo of Toby and are in hot water when a local grocery store winds up using it.
Teddy throws a sleepover at PJ's apartment to forget about her anniversary with Spencer, while PJ and Emmett take care of their neighbor's pet rats while he's away. After Verne quits working for Bob to start his extermination business, Bob hires a young man named Beau (Luke Benward), as a replacement. Amy and Ms. Dabney use Gabe and Lauren to trick each other to do their chores but tables turn when Gabe and Lauren find out.