When Rick reels in an antique glass fishing buoy made in Japan, he hopes the seller's price floats his boat. Meanwhile, Chum checks out a rare dinosaur fossil. Can he dig up a good price, or will the seller have a bone to pick with him? Then, a customer brings in an original poster for the film "Where the Buffalo Roam." Will Rick draw up a deal, or will he want it gonzo? And later, Rick and Corey head to the range to test out a 1580 German "puffer" pistol. Is it a wheely good deal, or a misfire?
Spencer drops into the shop with some tasty new finds, but will Rick bite? Then, Chum and Rick disappear from the shop to meet up with a magician selling a zig zag box. Can they conjure up an offer? Meanwhile, Corey finds himself flustered over a pricey gold necklace made of ancient coins. And later, Chum tries to script the perfect deal for a collection of Hollywood items.
When a friend swings by to show Rick and Chum a star-studded collection of photos, will the duo expose the right price, or get shot down? Then, a vintage LP of the single "We Are the World" spins into the shop. Will this deal make a brighter day for Corey? Meanwhile, Chum and Santos give each other a hand, when they check out an ancient Chinese cannon. Can they get a firm hold on this deal, or will it implode? And later, Rick races to Adam Carolla's garage for a chance to bid on a car once owned by legendary actor, Paul Newman. Will Rick do a victory lap, or will he be left in the dust?