Over eight years, the infamous Black Widower Thomas Randolph stands trial for the murder of his wife and her handyman; the victims' families are ready to see justice served, but a surprise ruling from the Nevada Supreme Court threatens everything.

Thomas Randolph has a dark past: he's been married six times, and four of his wives are dead; the families of his late wives, and the wives that survived him paint a dark portrait of his history in the lead up to his trial.

After the shooting of Sharon Causse in an apparent home invasion, detectives question who committed the crime: her handyman or her husband, Thomas Randolph; as police dig, they discover Sharon's murder wasn't the only death surrounding Randolph.