Expectant moms get readings before they give birth, including one who connects with her father, whom she believes answered her prayers to get pregnant after a miscarriage. Later, Theresa helps a woman whose father died on Thanksgiving; and another whose younger brother passed away after a series of illnesses stemming from a tick bite.
Larry Jr. visits Theresa in Florida while his father is out of town and takes his mom on a series of adventures, including riding a Jet Ski. Later, Theresa surprises a class at a dance studio with a group reading; and a man interrupts his workout on the beach so Theresa can talk to his mom on the phone.
The Caputos go to Florida to see if it's the right place for them in the winter. Meanwhile, Theresa tries a new hair salon and channels the brother of another customer; comforts a family dealing with the death of their son; and holds a group meeting that includes a woman whose best friend was shot and killed.
In the season premiere, Theresa reads for celebrities, including Jim Parsons, who connects with an old friend, and Susan Lucci, who is stunned by the messages she received. Also: Jamie-Lynn Sigler and her mother are overcome by emotion; and Katie Lowes comes to Theresa's house for a private reading.