Tina throws Christopher and Justin a joint birthday party while their fathers, Bobby and Nicky, compete to buy the most expensive luxury car for their sons.
Tina convinces Nicky to take a live lamb into his house until it can be slaughtered in a ritual meant to restore Bob, Sr's health, but runs into trouble when his wife, Christine, finds their son Justin alone with "Lamb Chop."
For decades the Johns men have run psychic shops, but Bobby decides to break tradition and expand his business empire with an investment in his son-in-law John's scrap-yard.
The Johns brothers get news that their father Bob has been rushed to the hospital. When the issue of consent divides the family, a fight breaks out between Nicky and Bobby, leaving their father's life hanging in the balance.
Rival brothers Bobby and Nicky come to blows in the boxing ring and the surprise arrival of Chris's baby puts pressure on Bobby to find a new psychic shop - and fast.