Frank Pinello visits the self-proclaimed "pizza capital of the world" Old Forge, Pennsylvania. This small town of just over 9,000 people has over twenty pizzerias, all serving a unique rectangular pizza that has its very own lingo. Frank visits Old Forge staples like Arcaro, Genell and Revello's.

Frank brings his pizza to Danny Meyer's Roman-style pizzeria Marta for a night of pizza dueling.